PECULIARITIES OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION OF NATIONAL MEMORY POLICY ON THE EXAMPLE OF THE MONUMENT TO CATHERINE II IN ODESA
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.main##
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.sidebar##
Abstract
Given the revision of the approach to assessing national memory policy and its consideration as a component of national security, an important task for the state is to rethink approaches to shaping the public space of Ukrainian cities. This requires analyzing the entire existing structure of governing bodies, the legislative framework, and specific cases related to the symbols of Russian imperial policy. This is especially true in cities that are the subject of increased attention from Russia. In particular, in Odesa, the example of the monument to Catherine II is one of the most striking in highlighting the problematic issues of Ukraine's approach to public administration in the field of national memory policy. While studying the issues of public administration in the field of national memory in Ukraine on the example of the monument to Catherine II in Odesa, the author gained access to archival documents of local self-government bodies, studied open and news data, as well as existing case law and legislation of Ukraine, current and past, which allows systematizing the identified shortcomings and suggesting ways to address them at the legislative level.
How to Cite
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.details##
national memory, Odesa, public administration, legislation, court decision, public space, memory war
2. Bohdanovych, O. V. (2018). *Zhiznʹ arkhitektora Dmytrenko (1858–1918). K 160-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia i 100-letiiu so dnia smerti* (*The Life of Architect Dmytrenko (1858–1918). For the 160th Anniversary of Birth and the 100th of Death*) (2nd ed., rev. & enl.). Odesa: Astroprynt.
3. DW.(2022, December29). V Odesi demontuvaly pamiatnyk Kateryni II ta Suvorovu [In Odesa, the monument to Catherine II and Suvorov was dismantled]. Deutsche Welle. https://www.dw.com/uk/v-odesi-demontuvali-pamatnik-katerini-ii-ta-suvorovu/a-64236148
4. Długosz, J. (1711). *Historiae Polonicae libri XII*. Lipsiae. https://bit.ly/3ZJwqTn
5. Enigma.ua(2017). Katerina rozdoru [Catherine of discord]. Enigma.ua. https://enigma.ua/articles/katerina_rozdoru
6. Hetʹ kryvavu katiivnytsiu: odesyty vymahaiut prybraty pamiatnyk Kateryni II (*Down with the Bloody Executioner: Odesans Demand Removal of the Monument to Catherine II*). (2022, September 2). *USI*. https://usionline.com/het-kryvavu-kativnytsiu-odesyty-vymahaiut-prybraty-pam-iatnyk-kateryni- ii-ta-ii-spodvyzhnykam/ (in Ukrainian)
7. Hetʹ kryvavu tsarytsiu: v Odesi Katerynu khotily odiaknuty v kovpak kata (*Down with the Bloody Tsarina: In Odesa, They Wanted to Dress Catherine in an Executioner’s Hood*). (2022, September 2). *Dumskaya.net*. https://dumskaya.net/news/proch-krovavogo-palacha-v-odesse-ekaterinu-hotel-168372/ua/ (in Ukrainian)
8. Honcharuk, H. I. (1999). *Odesskoe protivostoyanie (1994–1998)* (*The Odesa Confrontation (1994–1998)*). Odesa: Astroprynt.
9. Istoryky zaproponuvaly shliakhy dekonstuktsii impersʹkoi spadshchyny (*Historians Proposed Ways to Deconstruct the Imperial Heritage*). (2017, December 4). *Ukrainskyi instytut natsionalnoi pamiati*. https://bit.ly/3P7rp24 (in Ukrainian)
10. Іvasi.news. (2019, October 27). 27 oktyabria 2007 goda v Odesse vo vtoroi raz otkryli pamiatnik Ekaterine II (On October 27,2007, the monument to Catherine II was reopened in Odesa for the second time). Ivasi.news. https://ivasi.news/odessa/27-oktyabrya-2007-goda-v-odesse-vo-vtoroy-razotkryli-pamyatnik-ekaterine-ii-video/
11. Kateryna II – zasnovnycya Odesy chy okupantka Khadzhybeju? (*Catherine II: Founder of Odesa or Occupier of Khadjibey?*). (2022, July 8). *Istorychna Pravda*. https://www.istpravda.com.ua/articles/2022/07/8/161537/ (in Ukrainian)
12. Kovalska-Pavelko, I. (2022). Viiny pam’yati, yak kljuchovy chinnyk formuvannya derzhavnoi polityky pam’yati v suchasnii Ukraini (*Memory Wars as a Key Factor in the Formation of State Memory Policy in Modern Ukraine*). *Krakowskie Studia Malopolskie*, 35(3), 7–26. https://doi.org/10.15804/ksm20220301 (in Ukrainian)
13. Kulyk, V.(2013). War of memories in the Ukrainian media. In J. Fedor, E. Rutten, & V. Zvereva (Eds), Memory, conflict, and new media: Web wars in post-socialist states (pp. 63–81). London: Routledge.
14. Mahaletskyi, A. (2022). Pam’yattevi studii ta istorychna pam’yat’ pro viiny i voenni konflikty: istoriografiya pytannya (*Memory Studies and Historical Memory of Wars and Military Conflicts: A Historiography of the Issue*). *Intermarium: History, Policy, Culture*, 10, 136–158. https://doi.org/10.35433/history.112035 (in Ukrainian)
15. Miting protiv ustanovki pamyatnika Ekaterine II v Odesse (*Protest Against the Installation of the Monument to Catherine II in Odesa*). (2007, June 20). *UNIAN*. https://photo.unian.net/photo/72614-miting-proti-ustanovki-pam-yatnika-katerini-ii-v-odesi
16. Motenko, Y., & Shyshkina, Y. (2024). Formuvannya oficiynoi modeli kolektyvnoi pam’yati pro Drugu Svitovu Viynu yak zasobu informaciyno-psihologychnogo vplyvu (na materialah Rosijskoi Federatsii) (*Shaping of the Official Model of Collective Memory about The World War II as a Means of Information-psychological Influence (on the Materials of The Russian Federation)*). *History Journal Of Yuriy Fedkovych Chernivtsi National University*, (1), 130–138. https://doi.org/10.31861/hj2024.58.130-138 (in Ukrai...
17. Na pamiatnyk Kateryni II v Tsentri Odesy nadiagly chervonyi kovpak kata (*A Red Executioner’s Hood Was Put on the Monument to Catherine II in Central Odesa*). (2022, November 2). *Suspilne Odesa*. https://suspilne.media/odesa/307852-na-pamatnik-katerini-ii-v-centri-odesi-nadagli-cervonij-kovpak-kata/ (in Ukrainian)
18. Nevidomi rozpysaly pamiatnyk Kateryni II i porivnialy yii z Putinem (*Unknown Persons Painted the Monument to Catherine II and Compared Her to Putin*). (2022, September 10). *Glavkom*. https://glavcom.ua/odesa/news/nevidomi-rozpisali-pamjatnik-katerini-ii-v-odesi-i-porivnjali-jiji-z-putinim-foto--874453.html (in Ukrainian)
19. Novye istorii Odesy: biznesmen Ruslan Tarpan proviv ekskursiiu dlia hydov (*New Stories of Odesa: Businessman Ruslan Tarpan Led a Tour for Guides*). (2016, April 30). *Odeskyi visnyk*, (16). https://web.archive.org/web/20160821222534/http://www.odvestnik.com.ua/issue/767/15878/
20. NU-NS: vidkryttia pamiatnyka Kateryni II – naruha nad pamiattiu tysiach zakatovanykh (*NUNS: The Unveiling of the Monument to Catherine II is an Outrage to the Memory of Thousands Tortured*). (2007, October 25). *Korrespondent.net*. https://bit.ly/3BF3hk8 (in Ukrainian)
21. Obminiaty pamiatnyk Kateryni na yevropeiskoho yenota (*Exchange the Monument to Catherine for a Raccoon from Kherson Zoo*). (n.d.). *Elektronni petytsii*. https://petition.president.gov.ua/petition/169564 (in Ukrainian).
22. Odeska miskrada.(1995, June 02). Rishennia № 204 «Pro povernennia deiakym vulytsiam, provulkam, ploshcham, parkam ta skveram mista Odesy yikh istorychnykh nazv» [Decision No. 204
«On Returning Historical Names to Certain Streets, Lanes, Squares, Parks and Gardens in the City of Odesa»]. Ddepartament arkhivnoi spravy ta dilovodstva Odeskoi miskoi rady.
23. Palamarchuk, Yu. D., & Mielekestsev, K. I. (2023). Postkolonialʹna pamiatʹ i superechky navkolo imperatrytsi Kateryny II v Ukraini (*Postcolonial Memory and Controversies around Empress Catherine II in Ukraine*). *Visnyk studentsʹkoho naukovoho tovarystva DonNU im. V. Stusa*, 1(15), 57–62. (in Ukrainian)
24. Postanova 03.04.2019 r. u spravi № 2a-549/11 (*Resolution of April 3, 2019 in Case № 2a-549/11*). *Verkhovnyi sud*. https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/80930656
25. Postanova Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy vid 12.11.2014 r. № 684. *Deiaki pytannia Ukrainsʹkoho instytutu natsionalʹnoi pamiati* (*Some Issues of the Ukrainian Institute of National Memory*). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/684-2014-п#Text
26. Postanova Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy vid 13.09.2024 r. № 1066. *Pro vnesennia zmin shchodo diialʹnosti Ministerstva kultury ta stratehichnykh komunikatsii...* (*On Amendments Concerning the Activities of the Ministry of Culture and Strategic Communications...*). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1066-2024-п#n35
27. Postanova Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy vid 16.10.2019 r. № 885. *Deiaki pytannia diialʹnosti Ministerstva kultury, molodi ta sportu* (*Some Issues of the Ministry of Culture, Youth and Sports*). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/885-2019-п/ed20191016#Text
28. Postanova Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy vid 03.09.2014 r. № 495. *Pro zatverdzhennia Polozhennia pro Ministerstvo kultury Ukrainy* (*On Approval of the Regulation on the Ministry of Culture of Ukraine*). Kabinet Ministriv Ukrainy. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/495-2014-п#Text
29. Postanova vid 20.05.2008 r. u spravi № 3/92 (*Resolution of May 20, 2008 in Case № 3/92*). *Okrushchnyi administratyvnyi sud mista Kyieva*. https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/1874042 (in Ukrainian)
30. Pro demontazh ta perenesennia pamiatnyka (*On the Dismantling and Relocation of the Monument*). Rishennia vid 30.11.2022 № 1044-VIII. *Odeska miska rada*. https://omr.gov.ua/ua/acts/council/196279/
31. Pro nadannia zhodu na pryiniattia do komunalʹnoi vlasnosti... (*On the Consent to Accept into Municipal Ownership the Reconstructed Monument to the Founders of Odesa*). Rishennia vid 10.07.2008 r. № 2918-V. *Odeska miska rada*. Fond 151, opys 8, sprava 7521.
32. Pro peremishchennia pamiatky «Potomkintsiam-nashchadky» (*On the Relocation of the Monument ‘To the Descendants of the Potemkinites*). Rishennia vid 27.06.2006 r. № 97-V. *Odeska miska rada*. Fond 151, opys 8, sprava 6550.
33. Pro Pologhennia pro Ministerstvo kultury Ukrainy (*On the Regulation of the Ministry of Culture of Ukraine*). Ukaz vid 06.04.2011 r. № 388/2011. *Prezydent Ukrainy*. https://ips.ligazakon.net/document/U388_11
34. Pro restavratsiui ta blahoustrii Katerynynsʹkoi ploshchi (*On the Restoration and Improvement of Katerynynska Square*). Rishennia vid 04.07.2007 r. № 1401-V. *Odeska miska rada*. Fond 151, opys 8, sprava 6975.
35. Pro vidtvorennia istorychnoho oblychchia m. Odesy (*On the Restoration of the Historical Appearance of the City of Odesa*). Rishennia vid 02.06.1995 r. № 205. *Odeska miska rada*. Fond 151, opys 8, sprava 3874.
36. Pro vnesennia zmin do deiakykh aktiv KMU shchodo diialʹnosti Ministerstva kultury ta informatsiinoi polityky (*On Amendments to Some Acts of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the Activities of the Ministry of Culture and Information Policy*). Postanova vid 23.03.2020 r. № 231. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/231-2020-п/ed20200323#Text
37. Pro zatverdzhennia Polozhennia pro Ministerstvo kultury i turyzmu Ukrainy (*On the Approval of the Regulation on the Ministry of Culture and Tourism of Ukraine*). Postanova vid 08.11.2006 r. № 1566. *Kabinet Ministriv Ukrainy*. https://www.kmu.gov.ua/npas/54093218
38. Protokol XV sesii Odesʹkoi misʹkoi rady VIII sklykannia (*Protocol of the 15th Session of Odesa City Council, 8th Convocation*). (2022, September 28). *Odeska miska rada*. https://omr.gov.ua/ua/city/council/protocols/ (in Ukrainian)
39. Protokol zasidannia komisii z pytannia zniattia pamiatnyka Yekateryni II bez poshkodzhennia vid 20 kvitnia 1917 roku (*Protocol of the Commission on the Removal of the Monument to Catherine II Without Damage, April 20, 1917*). Derzhavnyi arkhiv Odesʹkoi oblasti, F. 3839, OP 1, SPR 14, ark. 18.
40. Putin è un folle ma ama Odessa. Sulla Crimea io dico che è meglio trattare (*Putin is Crazy But Loves Odesa. About Crimea I Say It's Better to Negotiate*). (2022, August 28). *Corriere della sera*. https://bit.ly/3ZKbP17
41. UNIAN. (2007, September19). Yushchenko mae odne prokhannia do odesytiv (Yushchenko has one request for Odesa residents). UNIAN. https://www.unian.ua/society/65464-yuschenko-mae-odne-prohannya-do-odesitiv.html
42. V Odesi zaminyty pamiatnyk Kateryni II na pamiatnyk amerykansʹkomu aktoru Billi Herrinhtonu (*Replace the Monument to Catherine II in Odesa with a Monument to American Actor Billy Herrington*). (n.d.). *Elektronni petytsii*. https://bit.ly/3VLbXMP (in Ukrainian)
43. Vidpovid Prezydenta Ukrainy na elekronnu petytsiiu № 22/141740-ep (*Response of the President of Ukraine to E-petition № 22/141740-ep*). (n.d.). *Elektronni petytsii*. https://petition.president.gov.ua/petition/141740 (in Ukrainian)
44. Vona nenavydila ukraintsiv, yak i Putin: v Odesi pamiatnyk Kateryni II oblyly chervonoiu farboiu (*She Hated Ukrainians Like Putin: In Odesa, the Monument to Catherine II Was Doused with Red Paint*). (2022, September 14). *TSN*. https://tsn.ua/ukrayina/ce-vzhe-vtretye-za-chotiri-dni-v-odesi-pam-yatnik-katerini-ii-oblili-chervonoyu-farboyu-foto-2157283.html (in Ukrainian)
45. Yak maie buty vyrishena dolia pamiatnyka 'Zasnovnykam Odesy', rozmishchenoho na Katerynynsʹkii ploshchi u m. Odesi? (*How Should the Fate of the Monument to the Founders of Odesa on Katerynynska Square Be Resolved?*). (n.d.). https://citizen.omr.gov.ua/discussion/2022-14/ (in Ukrainian)
46. Yang, G. (2023, May 3). China’s National Memory Laws and the War on Storytelling. *Australian Institute of International Affairs*. https://www.internationalaffairs.org.au/australianoutlook/chinas-national-memory-laws-and-the-war-on-storytelling/
47. Wilson Center. (2021, December 10). Kennan Long View Series | Weak Strongman: The Limits of Power in Putin's Russia. https://www.wilsoncenter.org/event/kennan-long-view-series-weak-strongman-limits-power-putins-russia
48. Zakon Ukrainy vid 06.07.2005 r. № 2747-IV. *Kodeks administratyvnogo sudochynstva Ukrainy* (*Code of Administrative Justice of Ukraine*). Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2747-15#Text
49. Zakon Ukrainy vid 09.04.2015 r. № 314-VIII. *Pro pravovyi status ta vshanuvannia pamiati bortsiv za nezalezhnistʹ Ukrainy u XX stolitti* (*On the Legal Status and Honoring of Fighters for Ukraine’s Independence in the 20th Century*). Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/314-19#Text
50. Zakon Ukrainy vid 09.04.2015 r. № 317-VIII. *Pro zasudzhennia komunistychnoho ta natsional-sotsialistychnoho (natsystsʹkoho) totalitarnykh rezhymiv* (*On the Condemnation of Communist and National-Socialist (Nazi) Totalitarian Regimes*). Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/317-19#Text
51. Zakon Ukrainy vid 12.11.2014 r. № 684-2014-p. *Pro blahoustrii naselenykh punktiv* (*On the Improvement of Settlements*). Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/684-2014-п#Text
52. Zakon Ukrainy vid 21.03.2023 r. № 3005-IX. *Pro zasudzhennia ta zaboronu propahandy rosiisʹkoi imperatorsʹkoi polityky* (*On the Condemnation and Prohibition of Propaganda of Russian Imperial Policy*). Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3005-20#Text
53. Zakon Ukrainy vid 24.05.2012 r. № 4865-IV. *Pro prysvoennya yurydychnym osobam ta ob’iektam prava vlasnosti imen...* (*On Naming Legal Entities and Objects of Property Rights after Individuals...*). Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/4865-17#Text
54. Zakon Ukrainy vid 28.11.2006 r. № 376-V. *Pro Holodomor 1932–1933 rokiv v Ukraini* (*On the Holodomor of 1932–1933 in Ukraine*). Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/376-16#Text